i've liked irs and madagascar from day one, through today, without wavering. other songs like cd and itw fall in and out of my graces at times. irs showcases some good energy and excellent vocals, whether the lyrics are generic or not. its a rocker it doesn't need to be deep. madagascar is powerful. i would love to har slash's take on both of these songs without messing with the overall structure of them. i voted better to save madagascar.

irs is solid. noone seems to hate it. intro to cd and all of the layers ruin the song for me. album  version of CITR destroys CD IMO.

its amazing how seeing the songs live changes my opinion of them.  I always skipped Prostitute when i was listening to the album regularly but it has grown on me after seeing it live. Still not my favorite by any stretch but I voted off ITW, a song i used to like....no staying power i guess.

i actually think catcher is a better written song than twat.

twat has better guitar peformance on it and that is what everyone always states as the reason for liking the song, along with axl's screams.
take away twats solo and axls screams and what do you really have? a decent song imo. the chorus and versus are nothing speial IMO.

catcher is still recognized as a good song by most even with the shitty solo and overproduction.

add slash or bucket to catcher and keep twat teh same id put them neck to neck, objectively, and still prefer catcher, personally.