You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#21 Re: Guns N' Roses » Haters » 84 weeks ago
dave-gnfnr wrote:Bill Brasky wrote:Sir Caram aka the butcher. Put so many layers of sound with bad dubs and poorly inserted Bumbleefoot gutairs that what was once clearly a natural sounding album became a copy paste nightmare.
Now bob luwdwig is clearly a master at his craft look no further the the brother in arms dire straits re release.
Sound perfection.Evil Joe is freedom fighter so the blame
Falls on Caram as it should.But we are all entitled to opinions.
Caram couldnt even mix hard school right
It sounds like Axl is singing through a tin can and string and Slashs guitar sounds like a midi fileAxl is always loyal to the wrong people.
yup sad but true
#22 Re: Guns N' Roses » Haters » 84 weeks ago
Kikkoman80 wrote:I wanted to know something....I'm Italian and here there are some forums where some people say that CHINESE DEMOCRACY is a bad record. I get pissed off because it's a great record. If you listen to it it's a great record. In my opinion Anyone who says it's bad doesn't understand much.
What do you think?Sir Caram aka the butcher. Put so many layers of sound with bad dubs and poorly inserted Bumbleefoot gutairs that what was once clearly a natural sounding album became a copy paste nightmare.
Now bob luwdwig is clearly a master at his craft look no further the the brother in arms dire straits re release.
Sound perfection.Evil Joe is freedom fighter so the blame
Falls on Caram as it should.But we are all entitled to opinions.
Caram couldnt even mix hard school right
It sounds like Axl is singing through a tin can and string and Slashs guitar sounds like a midi file
#23 Re: Guns N' Roses » Haters » 84 weeks ago
I wanted to know something....I'm Italian and here there are some forums where some people say that CHINESE DEMOCRACY is a bad record. I get pissed off because it's a great record. If you listen to it it's a great record. In my opinion Anyone who says it's bad doesn't understand much.
What do you think?
Because it is bad. All the demos are better.
The reason a lot of people hate it is because slash is not on them
The reason other people hate them is bc they are too over produced
The more Axl piled on to the songs teh worse they got.
#24 Re: Guns N' Roses » The General and Monsters » 84 weeks ago
Axl S wrote:Listening to the cellphone clip again, now that I know what I am listening to and can hear the lyrics, it is a shame we never got to hear that version.
This version is fine but as much as Slash's contributions sound fine, the song clearly was not originally going for a blues rock guitar sound as part of it and what can be heard on that cellphone clip sounds much better.
The guitars sound bad ass on the cell phone clip. As much as I dig the leak, I would love to hear that version.
Same here
I like what Slash did on monsters, but I really want to hear how BH and Robin orginally did it
#25 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
darknemus wrote:A. I don't claim anything.
B. I don't believe there is another 'village disc'
C. I had no specific goals other than mild amusement.
I have yet to see one scintilla of evidence of this fabled 20th 'village CD'.. and honestly I think a large part of why people think it exists is because the # 19 just seems 'weird'. Show me actual evidence and I'll reevaluate my opinion.
Take the absolute randomness of all the songs on the 19 discs.. do you think for some reason disc 20 had all the 'good stuff'? like.. what would lead you to draw said conclusion WHEN COMPARED TO how the material was spread among the other 19 discs. Let's say there is a 20th disc.. for all we know its 10 mixes of "Quick Song".. see what I'm saying?
I swear this band and the antics within it and surrounding it cause people to just say "F it" when it comes to even the most remedial of critical thinking skills.. boggles the mind.
And I'll state, YET AGAIN - if I had something you didn't have.. you'd have it.. because I don't play those games.
Thank you for response and sir I'm not talking about the 20th disc.
There's a helluva alot more then one disc out there.
What was leaked or acquired by the Mississippi playboy is just a page of the menu and the menu is the size of a classic dinners.
Sir i encourage everyone to read between the lines also read the amazingly well researched and written Chinese whispers.
Many of the individual artists who worked on said material have spoken in detail regarding the fact they kept working on the same songs over and over and have stated the estimated amount of completed full songs.
Now some of us old timers remember after the 02 tour that Axl took his ball and went home and only briefly did some recording in 06 in new york city.
We also can remember after Jeff leads nyt article came out that umg wasn't paying for anymore studio time by 2005.
That's just a brief verifiable statement.
Once again thank you for your response.
yeah Axl said back in 2002 they had two albums done and about 10 extra tracks
#26 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
Only in GNR land does this kind of thing happen lol
#27 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
Here's the link to Blackmountainthunder through the "EOY" upload
he uploaded yesterday lol
#28 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
The Void wrote:Tmgladden wrote:Uploaded 4 hours ago though, we got the link 7. He could have just snagged n dragged it to YouTube
I got word that it was shared around days ago so i don’t know anymore by this point. More info about this would be nice
Spoke too soon it is indeed a fan remix by BlackmountainThunder so there you go
Where is the evidence its from BlackmountainThunder?
Did he post it online before it leaked or parts of it? What is the link to his youtube channel.
#29 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
dave-gnfnr wrote:Shacklermyrye wrote:I'm torn on this one now
torn about what
As to if it's real or a collection of bucket samples layered over a locker leak.
I doubt someone would fake eye on you of all songs but maybe if someone brings it to a BH forum they will know if these guitar parts come from any other songs of his
I listened to it a few times, it is interesting. sometimes the guitar match up the song and other times it doesnt, but again Axl was copy and pastig alot during this time, so he could have just taken random guitar parts that BH or Finck laid down and put them on the song.
#30 Re: Guns N' Roses » eye on you disc? » 84 weeks ago
I'm torn on this one now
torn about what
