if the song was sang and written by jonas brothers, i would like it, i'd certainly be like "what the fuck!?!?" but regardless, i'd like it. saying people love this song solely because Axl wrote it, is so ignorant its almost infuriating. this is the first negative review i have seen, and the guy is clearly an idiot. he contradicts himself so badly that he loses all credibility, how can something sound dated and still be a hit on modern radio stations? the guy is clearly an imbecile.

ah-uh honeycomb its shopped i know these things

yea i know, wheres a link to the site you got it from ellipse, ellipse, ellipses

i don't give a shit what the songs about. the point is the lyrics are terrible, the song could be about child molestation or something equally as delicate, doesn't mean i am required to respect it solely because the song is about a controversial topic. and if it is about domestic violence, than the accompanying video, which takes place in iraq, is undeniably out of place(i am not saying it isn't about domestic violence, the laughable lyrics certainly indicate that). the song possesses some of the worst lyrics i HAVE EVER SEEN. metallica fanboys continue to cry all you want, doesn't change the fact that its an atrocious song.

who is saying death magnetic is good? the only positive review it has received thus far was so obviously a puff piece, the link to the review was on metallica's website, by a guy who had the 'exclusive' opportunity to hear it before its release, the same guy who gave st anger an A-. every other review has been luke-warm to scathing.

if anyone says "OH YOU MEAN LIKE CHINESE DEMOCRACY LEAKS REVIEWS?!?!??!", i'll track them down and hurt them. i cannot stand the people who write that horse shit. i haven't read one negative professional review, in fact the only times i have seen negative comments about the leaks, seem to be in passing, on some sensationalist media website eg. "Axl rose has been working on the album for 15 years at a cost of 15 million dollars, 9 tracks leaked off the album all receiving harsh reviews", TIME magazine gave the leaks an overall B+, with individual song scores ranging from A+ to C+, rolling stone seemed almost ecstatic about the leaks, while other reviews are generally lukewarm to great, i cannot for the life of me cite one scathing review of the chinese democracy leaks.

if theres anyone reading this who is anti-review/critic, eg. "ILL BE THE JUDGE OF THE METALLICA ALBUM MYSELF" or "I'D RATHER LISTEN TO THE FAN'S OPINIONS ON IT", check out 'the day that never comes' on youtube, you'll wish the day never ever ever came! OH MY GOD HOW PUNNY OF ME! by the same token the fan's perspective of 'death magnetic' is largely negative, check blabbermouth, or sputnikmusic.