Son of a Gun wrote:

RussTCB wrote:

I like Frank far better for GN'R than either Brain or Freese.

Weird, but to each his own.

I used to talk up Brain over Frank too, but Frank won me over seeing him live. He's a really great rock drummer, and seems to combine both Matt's and Steven's styles into his own.

Brain is technically the better drummer, but I don't think he ever really fit with GN'R's style.

And yeah, Josh Freese is great too, especially the footage I've seen of him from touring with NIN.

Son of a Gun wrote:

otto wrote:

...Robin Finck quit in 2007 and Axl wanted to replace him with Slash? By Slash's demand, Duff would be on board as well. So we would have a line-up like this:

Axl
Slash
Duff
Bumblefoot
Richard Fortus
Frank Ferrer
Dizzy Reed
Chris Pitman

They would then add Slash parts to Chinese Democracy songs, have a slightly different tracklist and release it and tour behind the album in 2008/2009.

Let Ferrer fuck off replace him with Brain or Josh Freese and I`m down with that lineup.

Huge fan of Brain, but Frank is pretty cool to me.

Ali

More live dates to make excuses for not writing or recording...